Jul 29 2008
An Engagement CONTRACT?
Okay, sometimes the news of the day just baffles me.
Recently a woman in Georgia was awarded $150,000 from her ex-fiance because he called of the wedding. She claimed that he set a wedding date, gave her a ring and asked her to leave an $81,000 a year job to move back to Georgia and marry him.
Then, within a few months, he cancelled the wedding and the two split up. She has replaced her old job with one making $31,000 a year and blames her ex for the loss of salary among other things.
I understand her anger and I have definitely seen engagements break up when one person deserves to be compensated by the other. One friend broke up with her fiancé after he proved that he couldn’t put her first. She left the relationship much poorer, having put numerous mutual expenses and even child support for his son from an earlier relationship on her credit card. All the bills in their shared apartment were in her name and he never paid his portion of those either. In all, when she left she was about $5,000 poorer than when they met.
But she learned a good lesson and paid off her bills. She went on with her life. Technically, she was the one to break off the engagement and he was devastated. Should he have been able to sue her? Legally, she probably had standing to sue him as a non-paying roommate, but what about the heartache?
I think my friend would agree that the woman in Georgia made a dumb move giving up a good-paying job for the man she thought she was going to marry. My friend might even agree that the woman suffered because of the breakup, but I doubt she would agree that the spurned lover deserved a $150,000 settlement.
It seems to be too much like a reversion to the bad old days when women thought men were supposed to take care of them forever and never took responsibility for their own lives. Unfortunately, this woman made some horrid choices, but they were hers to make. She gave up that salary for the chance at happily ever after. The fact that she did not get it just makes her a part of mainstream America, not a victim.
This should join the McDonald’s scalding coffee lawsuit as further evidence that American society is far too litigious and people need to take responsibility for their own actions!